Getting a good night’s sleep starts with the right pillow insert. If you’ve ever woken up with a sore neck or just can’t seem to get comfortable, your pillow insert might be the culprit. In 2025, pillow inserts are more advanced, sustainable, and customizable than ever before. Let’s break down what makes the best pillow inserts this year, what to look for, and how to pick the perfect one for your needs.
Transform your comfort—explore Honeydew Sleep’s premium pillow collection and discover inserts that deliver real support and style.
Why Pillow Inserts Matter for Comfort and Style
A great pillow insert transforms a decorative cover into a plush, supportive cushion. The right insert:
-
Provides fullness and shape for a polished, “designer” look.
-
Offers support for lounging, napping, or back relief.
-
Lasts longer with high-quality fill and construction.
-
Adapts to your needs—from hypoallergenic to eco-friendly, indoor to outdoor.
Types of Pillow Inserts: Fill Materials and Benefits
1. Down & Feather Inserts
-
Luxury feel: Soft, plush, and “karate-choppable” for that hotel look.
-
Best for: Decorative pillows on sofas and beds.
-
Cons: Not hypoallergenic; requires regular fluffing; higher price.
2. Down Alternative Inserts
-
Hypoallergenic: Made from polyester or microfiber, mimicking down’s softness.
-
Easy care: Machine-washable, affordable, and available in all sizes.
-
Best for: Families, allergy sufferers, and high-traffic areas.
3. Polyester Fiber Inserts
-
Budget-friendly: Durable, supportive, and holds shape well.
-
Best for: Outdoor pillows, lumbar support, and value-conscious shoppers.
4. Foam Inserts
-
Supportive: Available in various densities, great for lumbar and seat cushions.
-
Best for: Back support, bolsters, and outdoor seating.
-
Cons: Not as plush for decorative use; may retain heat.
5. Natural Fill Inserts (Cotton, Latex, Wool)
-
Eco-friendly: Breathable, hypoallergenic, and sustainable.
-
Best for: Green-minded homes, those with sensitive skin.
What Size Pillow Insert Should You Buy?
-
Go bigger: For a full, plump look, choose an insert 1–2 inches larger than your pillow cover (e.g., 20x20 insert for an 18x18 cover).
-
Shape matters: Square is most common, but rectangular/lumbar and round inserts are great for layering and support.
-
Overstuffed inserts: Offer extra fullness and help maintain shape over time.
How to Choose the Best Pillow Insert for Your Space
-
Match your lifestyle: Kids or pets? Go for hypoallergenic, machine-washable down alternative or polyester.
-
Prioritize support: Need lumbar or back support? Choose foam or high-density polyester.
-
Go green: Opt for organic cotton, latex, or recycled fill for eco-friendly comfort.
-
Mix and match: Layer different sizes and shapes for a designer look.
-
Care instructions: Removable, washable covers and inserts are a must for easy maintenance.
Market Trends: Pillow Inserts in 2025
-
U.S. pillow market: Valued at $4.56 billion in 2024, projected to reach $6.77 billion by 2030 (CAGR 6.8%).
-
Customization: Adjustable and personalized inserts are on the rise, with more consumers seeking the perfect fit for their decor and comfort.
-
Sustainability: Recycled and organic materials, Oeko-Tex and CertiPUR-US certifications, and longer-lasting designs are in demand.
-
Digital print pillows: Custom-printed inserts and covers are a fast-growing segment, especially among Gen Z and millennials.
Best Pillow Inserts in 2025
#1 – Honeydew Sleep: Best Pillow Inserts for Comfort and Support
Welcome to Honeydew Sleep, a family-operated business with a heartfelt mission to revolutionize the way the world sleeps. With over 50 years of collective experience in the sleep industry, we've witnessed firsthand the profound impact that the right pillow can have. Imagine starting every day feeling rejuvenated, pain-free, and bursting with energy — this is the dream we offer at Honeydew.
Craftsmanship and Passion in Every Pillow
Our pillows aren’t just made; they’re crafted with precision, care, and genuine passion. From the luxurious fabrics to the innovative design, every component of our pillows is selected for its superior quality and ability to deliver an exceptional sleep experience. The attention to detail extends from the carefully selected fill materials to each stitch and seam, ensuring that every product is a testament to our commitment and love for better sleep.
Why Choose Honeydew Sleep?
Buying a Honeydew pillow is more than a purchase—it's an investment in your health. A good night's sleep has the power to transform your day, boosting your energy levels, lifting your mood, and enhancing your overall quality of life. We at Honeydew Sleep want you to live at your absolute best:
-
Rediscover Vitality: Wake up refreshed and ready to take on the day with vigor.
-
Upgrade Your Comfort: Experience the ultimate comfort designed for your specific sleep needs.
-
Embrace Joyful Mornings: Let go of morning grogginess and embrace a lifestyle filled with enthusiasm.
We are proud of our products and confident that you will cherish your Honeydew pillow just as much as we enjoy crafting them. Become a part of our family and embrace a life of energy, happiness, and impeccable comfort. Start transforming your life, one night at a time.
Join us on our mission: Improve lives, enhance sleep, and help everyone rediscover their most vibrant, energetic, and joyous selves. You deserve it.
Our Best Pillow - Honeydew Sleep
Description (The Scrumptious Side Pillow):
Experience unparalleled comfort with our unique Scrumptious Side Pillow, specially designed to cradle your neck and shoulders perfectly. Its distinctive curve aligns your spine while you rest, providing both comfort and support. The proprietary fill not only offers a luxurious feel but also excels in alleviating neck and shoulder discomfort.
Money Back Guarantee
You can try our pillow risk-free! We proudly offer a 60-night money-back guarantee on all purchases.
Dimensions & Specifications
Our pillows are as exceptional in size as they are in comfort. Designed deliberately with our unique fill, these pillows come in specific dimensions and weights to optimize your sleep quality:
-
Queen Size: Approximately 27" x 15"
-
King Size: Approximately 30" x 17"
Each box includes one Scrumptious Side Pillow (note: pillowcase sold separately).
Care Instructions
Caring for your pillow is easy:
-
Use a machine washable (and tumble dry) cover.
-
Remove the fill before washing.
-
Utilize the hidden zipper on the back for easy maintenance.
To enhance the pillow's hygiene and feel, consider using our high-quality pillowcases, which are not only easy to wash and dry but also make your pillow more breathable and incredibly soft.
Warranty Information
Our commitment to quality is backed by a 3-year limited warranty that covers any defects in materials and workmanship.
Transform your sleep with the Scrumptious Side Pillow — designed for ultimate comfort and perfected for your wellness.
→ Take time to discover our products
→ Also our product on Amazon: Honeydew Scrumptious Cooling Side Sleeping Pillow for Adults | Best for Side Sleepers | for Neck and Shoulder Pain Relief | Neck Support Pillows for Sleeping | Made in The USA (Queen Size)
The Classic Scrumptious Pillow
Description (The Classic Scrumptious Pillow)
The Classic Scrumptious Pillow features the distinct fill and fabric seen in our Scrumptious Side Pillow but presents it in the traditional rectangular pillow shape.
COMPLIMENTARY SHIPPING ACROSS THE NATION
We are pleased to offer complimentary shipping on all orders exceeding $50 within the United States. (See Full Details)
SATISFACTION GUARANTEE
Every purchase comes with a 60-night satisfaction guarantee. (See Full Details)
PRODUCT DIMENSIONS & DETAILS
Our pillows stand apart, defined by unique dimensions and weights, guided by our exceptional fill. These characteristics are intentionally selected to ensure your optimal sleep experience.
Here's what to expect:
• The Queen size is approximately 27" x 15"
• The King size is approximately 30" x 17"
MAINTENANCE INSTRUCTIONS
All our pillows come with machine-washable covers that can also be tumble-dried. Simply remove the fill using the discreet zipper at the back before washing.
For optimal cleanliness and to extend the life of your pillow, we recommend using one of our superb pillowcases. They not only shield your pillow but are also effortless to launder, enhancing the cooling effect and offering unparalleled softness. Your skin will surely appreciate it :)
WARRANTY
This product is protected by a 3-year limited warranty that covers material and manufacturing defects.
For the comprehensive warranty details, click (here).
→ Take time to discover our products
→ See also our product on Amazon: Honeydew Classic Scrumptious Pillow – Made in USA with Cooling Copper Gel Fill – Adjustable Bed Pillow for Back & Stomach Sleepers with Neck and Shoulder Pain, Quick Pain Relief (Queen Size)
Contact Us
Customer Service & Information
- 📧 Email: info@honeydewsleep.com
Sales
- 📧 Email: sales@honeydewsleep.com
Press
- 📧 Email: press@honeydewsleep.com
Phone Contact
- 📞 Call or Text: (805) 477-9990
- 🕒 Phone Hours: Monday-Friday 10 AM-4 PM PST
Mailing Address
- 📬 Honeydew Sleep Co.
- 📍 1010 Lawrence Drive, Newbury Park, CA 91320
Feeling more traditional? Send us a letter to our physical address!
See more Pillows by Honeydew Sleep
#2 Lincove Luxury Throw Pillow Insert
A premium down-alternative insert featuring a 100% cotton shell and vegan-friendly polyester microgel fill. Known for its plush, hypoallergenic comfort, this insert is available in a variety of sizes and includes double-stitched edging for durability. It’s designed for maximum coziness and support, making it ideal for couches, beds, and decorative use. The insert maintains its shape and offers a cloud-like feel, perfect for those seeking a luxury look without allergens.
#3 EDOW Throw Pillow Insert
Editor’s Choice for value and versatility, the EDOW insert comes in a set of two and is available in multiple sizes. It features a 100% cotton cover with tight stitching to prevent fill leaks, and the polyester fiber fill provides a soft, supportive feel. Machine-washable and easy to maintain, this insert is a favorite for those who want a plush, affordable option for decorative pillows and shams.
#4 Phantoscope 18x18 Pillow Inserts (Set of 4)
Made in the USA with American-made virgin micro-fiber filling and high-quality polyester covers, these hypoallergenic inserts are known for their high filling capacity and resilience. They offer extra comfort and support, making them suitable for accent pieces or back support. The inserts are vacuum-packed for shipping and fluff up quickly, and they’re washable for easy care—ideal for allergy sufferers and busy households.
#5 Pillowflex Synthetic Down Alternative Pillow Insert
Renowned for its wide range of size options, the Pillowflex insert uses a synthetic down alternative fill that mimics the feel of real down while remaining hypoallergenic. It’s designed for fullness and shape retention, making it a go-to for decorators and homeowners who want a plush, supportive look. The insert is machine-washable and durable, fitting a variety of covers and shams for both decorative and functional use.
Transform your comfort—explore Honeydew Sleep’s premium pillow collection and discover inserts that deliver real support and style.
